In marking Elvis Presley’s 80th birthday today my thoughts
drifted back to the initial spark that he ignited in a small Memphis recording
studio sixty years ago, which jump-started his career and also kindled the rock
‘n’ roll revolution. In the first week
of July, 1954, Elvis, Scotty Moore, and Bill Black assembled for the first time
in Sam Phillips’ small Sun Records studio.
Their goal was to cut at least a couple of decent tracks for the combo’s
first single. It was a truly magical moment,
the likes of which may never be seen again.
I tried to capture it in words seventeen years ago and I offer an
excerpt from that effort today as my birthday card and thank-you note to the King.
“From the date of his first recording session at Sam
Phillips' Sun studio, Elvis rapidly evolved from a somewhat unsure balladeer to
a music dynamo who changed popular music more than any individual performer
ever had, or ever would again. It is
fortunate that many of his earliest recordings have survived, for through them
his meteoric rise can be witnessed again and again. But for that to happen, listeners must
mentally place themselves in the mainstream pop music world that existed in
1954 America. Only then can the
revolutionary nature of what happened at Sun Records be appreciated. Seemingly mild by today's rock standards,
most of these recordings still sound fresh and exciting, although some
listeners may consider them mere curiosities from a seemingly quaint period,
before anyone had even imagined heavy metal, synthesizers, samples, or outdoor
stadium rock shows. Placed in the
context of their time, however, they are anything but quaint or
unexciting.
“It is interesting that, up until he spontaneously
burst into ‘That's All Right', Elvis had seemed determined to confine
his public and recorded efforts strictly to ballads, and may well have regarded
himself as primarily a crooner. His most
prominent idol was Dean Martin, who sang in a relaxed, carefree style that
Elvis admired and emulated. He adopted
Martin's sliding vocal swoops, and his demo of ‘My Happiness’ might even be
viewed as an early, poor imitation of Martin.
"‘That's All Right’ was spontaneous, not
planned, beginning during a break from recording. Elvis knew Arthur ‘Big Boy’ Crudup's original
recording well, and in fact changed it very little, retaining the same tempo,
even including the ‘Dee, dee, dee-dee’ chorus, but altering a few lyrics and
investing it with a touch of country flavor.
But once Sam Phillips heard it and encouraged the group to keep moving
in that direction, Elvis and the others rapidly shed whatever inhibitions they
may have had. There is even a noticeable
increase in the free-spirited nature of Elvis' performance when the final version
of the song is compared to a surviving earlier take.
“Again, it may be hard to believe or understand the
risk associated with doing such music at that time, but it was very clear to
Elvis, Scotty, Bill, and Sam. Moore
later recollected that his initial reaction upon hearing the recording was, ‘Well,
that's fine, but good God, they'll run us out of town!’ Elvis may have entered the studio convinced
that he wasn't supposed to sing that
way, with genuine inner feelings rather than the contrived style that went into
contemporary popular ballads, and which went down well with mid-1950s middle
America. Left to his own instincts,
however, it burst from him spontaneously, which was the sort of thing that Sam
Phillips had been hoping for, and which he quickly encouraged.
“‘Blue Moon of Kentucky’ was even more revisionist
and revolutionary. An early take shows a
startling leap in development from Bill Monroe's original bluegrass waltz to a
faster, livelier country shuffle, sufficiently new to prompt a gratified Sam
Phillips to exclaim, ‘Hell, that's fine.
That's different. That's a pop
song now, nearly about.’ How much more
revealing to then hear the final version, which takes the song far beyond that
level into an up-tempo arrangement that neither Bill Monroe, nor anyone else,
could have foreseen. Punctuated by the
percussive effect of Bill Black's slap bass, and paced by Elvis' urgent vocal,
matched by Scotty Moore's guitar, this was truly something new, and its
freshness is still there today.
“In these relatively few hours at Sun Records,
something monumental and irreversible had happened to popular music, and
forever altered it. Within a few years,
the artists and styles that dominated the pop charts would be replaced almost
entirely and forever by rock and roll music.
The sounds that emanated from Sam Phillips' tiny studio would resonate
across the Atlantic too, where they transfixed four Liverpool youngsters, who
would rescue and reinvent the music in their own image a decade later.
“Whether or not this really was the rock and roll
genesis, Elvis would soon come to personify rock and roll on a national and
international level, having made it acceptable to a broad audience, despite
considerable public outcry against him.
Elvis combined his broad musical influences into a new style and gave it
his own unique vocal brand. His was a
mature, masculine, suggestive, often threatening voice, not the thin tenor of
other, safer "teen idols" of the 1950s, such as Eddie Fisher. Before Elvis, there may not have been
‘nothing,’ as John Lennon once suggested, but there was certainly nothing like
this.”
Excerpted from “Elvis and the Rock
& Roll Genesis” by Allen J. Wiener; Discoveries
(July 1997).
Channeling Elvis: How Television Saved the King of
Rock ‘n’ Roll by Allen J. Wiener is available in paperback
and Kindle e-book editions from:
Amazon.com
in the U.S. at this link: http://tinyurl.com/mhyaouz;
In U.K. (paperback): http://tinyurl.com/kyolbnm; (Kindle): http://tinyurl.com/qdbk9cb
In U.K. (paperback): http://tinyurl.com/kyolbnm; (Kindle): http://tinyurl.com/qdbk9cb
Thanks for the post, Allen, very nice. The goal of the 5th July session was more likely just to see how Elvis sounded on tape with a small band, I'm not sure they were consciously attempting to cut a single. I'm also not 100% convinced of the legendary "spontaneous" theory -- Elvis was singing a number of Crudup lyrics withing one song on "That's All Right".
ReplyDeleteHi Allen, Tony.
ReplyDeleteBoth of you may find the following research enlightening, if you haven't already seen it. Gound-breaking work. Brilliant dude, whoever he is.
http://www.elvis-collectors.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=72871
Best,
Robin
Thanks Robin. That is very interesting! Thanks for posting!
ReplyDeleteTony - I think I responded on Facebook, but I don't doubt that Elvis knew the song quite well and had sung it many times and also knew other Crudup songs. In this one, he seems to conflate lyrics from more than one Crudup song, just as he conflated, or combined, Joe Turner's "Flip, Flop & Fly" with "Shake, Rattle & Roll" on his first "Stage Show" appearance. However, Elvis clung to ballads throughout this session, not intending to do any up-tempo numbers in his repertoire. Only during the break, or when they were getting ready to call it a night, did he spontaneously start singing "That's All Right," which caught Sam Phillips' ear and things then took a new direction.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Allen. How do you know that Elvis wasn't intending to play any uptempo songs at this"casual" session? (Genuine question, not meant to sound nasty.)
ReplyDeleteTony, that comes largely from Scotty's recollections, which are in Guralnick's book and which Scotty also mentioned to me. When he and Bill Black first met Elvis at Scotty's house to jam a bit (Sam Phillips had asked Scotty to work with Elvis and evaluate his singing), all Elvis seemed to know were slow ballads and that's all they did. When they gathered at Sun for the first time, he also kept doing "I Love You Because" and "Harbor Lights," but nothing really happened. When Elvis spontaneously burst into "That's All Right" it took them all by surprise. Phillips was especially surprised because everything he had heard Elvis do led him to believe he wasn't even familiar with that kind of music. So, up to that moment, all that any of these guys had heard Elvis do were slow ballads and that was clearly the direction Elvis thought he should go in. It's a bit puzzling, but when you realize that Sam Phillips himself was struggling to get people to listen to music outside the mainstream, it's not surprising that Elvis would think that kind of music did not offer him a future in recording, so he stuck to what he may have regarded as "commercial," trying to copy successful crooners of the era. I think he was as surprised as Scotty, Bill, and Sam were that this was the song that put him over. They were actually somewhat overtaken by events when the song created a stir in Memphis after Dewey Phillips played it on the radio and they had to scramble to come up with a B-side, which was "Blue Moon of Kentucky," another up-tempo arrangement. That one also was hit upon spontaneously at a later session that also seemed to be going nowhere. In fact, Elvis again reverted to ballads with "Blue Moon" on the night following recording of "That's All Right."
DeleteThank you for taking the time to answer so fully, Allen. I persist in my query because none of us can know of Elvis' actual INTENTIONS although we can all agree that he maintained a steady flow of ballads until the magic moment.
ReplyDeleteIt is possible that he WANTED to play uptempo or blues at the "session" but an opening never arrived. Scotty has said that they were just looking for something they (all three of them) knew how to play. Neither Scotty nor Bill were familiar with Crudup's work so it's possible that Elvis erred on the side of caution, not wanting to cause offence.
I do still believe that Smith's theory as posted on FECC remains possible and wonderful!
As for me, I think Smith's thesis is backed up pretty well by available evidence. I have to go back to Hopkins, but as I recall after "Without You, Elvis is said to have ran down very many songs, not necessarily confined strictly to ballads. "Rag Mop" was recalled. And at around that time, R&B balladry was quite popular. The Ink Spots seemed a particular favorite.
ReplyDeleteI just think Elvis wanted to please. Sam had done okay recently with The Prisonaires. Elvis both enjoyed Bragg's angelic singing, and perhaps thought Sam was looking for more of that. He was called down FOR a ballad.
But Sam really wasn't looking for genre; he was looking for feel. I read something not too long ago where Elvis said that after the failed "Western" type songs, "I just relaxed into my own style." I sure wish I had a citation. But I can't recall where. I do know that I read it. I am certain of that.
That is precisely what it sounds like. As though he relaxed and everything finally flowed.
As for Blue Moon, to my ears it sounds rehearsed and a very serious attempt at a record. It's genuis, but Sam just didn't want it. It's no ordinary ballad at all. Not in his version. If ever ever pop was transformed into a blues, this was it. Ernst Jørgenson makes such a claim in his liner notes to Platinum - A Life In Music.